Thursday, May 10, 2007

The Origins








Ever since I was a small boy, I always felt more comfortable around girls. Throughout elementary school, I only walked home and played with girls in school, my block, and all other social settings. Although many attempts were made on my part to interact with other boys, in many areas, be it homework, designing science projects, playing sports, or just being wild and fighting in the playground, little ever came of it. My father worked very hard to give me the all-American male upbringing, Little League, baseball, soccer, basketball, scouting, and other male-bonding rites of passage. We had a pitchback on our front lawn, so that every day that wasn't brutally cold, would have us there attempting to play baseball, quite often being interrupted by his screaming, "catch the ***&&%% ball, chucky, don't be afraid of it" . He became the little league coach, where I was further humiliated in front of all the other boys. In Cub Scouts, I was the only boy that could never tie the knots, learn any of the camping skills, or earn any of the Merit badges. Once again my father was the Troop leader, becoming very frustrated and embarrassing me in front of everyone.

JHS, especially in Public School, is extremely traumatic for anyone. However, it was infinitely more so for me, because as much as I tried and wanted to make friends, bond, and form solid rel-ships with other boys, it never happened. At the time, I was beginning to develop a strong interest in Yiddishkeit, and learning Torah. Every Shabbos, during walks home with the local Conservative Rabbi, someone from the old school, who learned in Torah V-Daas, not JTS, there was no end to my questions. Most went unanswered. This caused great internal turmoil. On the one hand, I now realized, it was important to relate to boys more, on the other, emotionally, this was extremely difficult and I never succeeded at it. In fact, the closest relationships in my adolescent years were with girls, and none of them became sexual.

If you are wondering about my orientation, I am 100% straight and for sure, there were tremendous taivos and thoughts like any healthy adolescent, going thru puberty, nevertheless none of thes friendships ever became physical.

By the time, I reached High School, there was really no point in denying my feelings, and the tremendous pressure of being in all Honors classes, and working hard to get all As, and do my best to assure getting into a good college left no energy, or mental/emotional abilities to fight it..As a result of this, whereas, in JHS, I took wood-shop, contact sports, and all male-dominated subjects and activities; in HS , I took Home Ec (cooking and sewing), tennis, golf, and swimming. Interestingly, I was able to convince the Phys Ed director to allow me to swim between periods, when the pool wasn’t being used, to avoid mixed swimming. For extra-curricular activities, I got very involved in Debate Club, Poetry Club, and a Literature extra-credit seminar that featured romance novels. An added benefit of was that extremely intelligent, cultured students were far more open-minded and accepting than the general school population. I developed many close relationships with very sweet girls as a result of this.

In 11th grade, after making the full commitment to become frum, a strange dichotomy came about. I wanted to avoid girls entirely to conform with halacha, but that was sort of like not breathing. The year started off with an eight week stint in a mainstream Yeshiva HS, far away from home, that was abysmally unproductive. The secular education provided was appalling; the Limudei Kodesh was at best satisfactory, however all the spoiled FFB kids didn’t take it seriously in the least bit , and it felt like JHS, all over again, this time in 24/7 mode sans bus stops and study halls..To make matters worse, a perpectual estrogen-free environment was absolutely unbearable. So I returned to my former HS until graduation.

After HS, I chose to go to Yeshiva instead of the several ivy league universities that I was accepted to. Boro Park proved to be a very repressive atmosphere. The stifling intense gender segregation and prevailing attitudes exacerbated matters immeasurably. The year or so there was absolute torture. Fortunately, I was able to find a very, nice, warm out-of-town Yeshiva, where things were more laid-back. I drove my Rebbe’s daughters all over, as well as, some of the local wives from time to time, when they needed to go shopping. Being able to socialize and converse with them relieved a lot of the pressure.

Over the years since then, technology has improved matters tremendously. My quality of life has benefited drastically with the introduction of the Internet, blogs, digital voice-changers and awesome makeover software.

So far, I have only gone out in public en-femme about twice, as I have tremendous apprehension about it, socially and halachically. I would like to use this blog to get feedback from other frum CDs, as well as, to explore my feelings..

9 comments:

Esti said...

HOW OLD ARE YOU? WHEN DID YOU START CROSSDRESSING? WHAT MADE YOU WANT TO?
MANY OF US FEEL CLOSER TO FEMALES.

FOR EVERY PSAK HALACHA AGAINST CROSSDRESSING, THERE IS ONE THAT SAYS IT'S OK.
GO AHEAD AND ENJOY YOUR FEMININITY AND DO NOT BE AFRAID TO GO OUT IF YOU FEEL CONFIDENT ENOUGH IN YOUR ABILITY TO PASS

Aviva Tamar said...

HI, Stephany, it's me, Genevieve, in a new personality! (For now.) I was very moved by your origins story. I can't say I felt the same way, which makes it obvious that a CD can come to this point from different directions.

On another subject, I see your Boro Park pictures are more "realistic" than those on the old J-A-P, obviously, and you did photo-shop the pic so no faces are shown, but for some reason it still doesn't seem right. And to tell you the truth, the ladies in these pics aren't exactly idealized visions of womanhood, even for a frum CD! (With all due respect to those ladies, of course). Now, if you took those pictures at a chasuna or something, then you might be on to something! But then again, if you have to mess with the face, you mess with their makeup, and that's an important item to a CD!

chaya said...

Hi Esti...welcome back. Nice to see you too.. Im in my 30s, just started in the last few years. In my private bedroom, Ive experimented since childhood, but only started publicly, the last few months. Will discuss it in future posts. Thanks for the encouragement.

Aviva...Id love to hear what motivated you.If you dont mind me saying so, your other two pictures were much nicer. The blonde was awesome.

As for the pics I posted, I just grabbed anything from my My Pics dir. Also, the one on this post just seems very sweet, gives me a warm feeling inside. Will try to post something more glamorous next time.

chaya said...

the last comment was from me, Stephany, having trouble with the display name..

Aviva Tamar said...

It takes a while to get used to blogging. To make things less confusing, I moved JAP to my own new account, so re-set your email under this blog so you can get email responses.

Aviva Tamar said...

I wish I could tell you what motivated me. I had no issues growing up, but when I was about 12 years old, and my parents were away, I had put on a pair of pantyhose and what looked like (very popular at the time) hotpants, a pair of my mom's high-heel pumps, and just loved how it all felt. It was also my first ejaculation experience, r"l. By why did I put on that clothing? I don't know.

Shoshana said...

Ok now it seems to be working . All boys that age are curious, what propelled it into adulthood in your case.

Aviva Tamar said...

In adulthood? I don't really know. Emes!

Side note to Esti: Can you tell us about the psak halacha that says it's OK?

Esti said...

TO MAKE IT SIMPLE..THE POSKIM THAT SAY CROSSDRESSING IS OK SAY THAT THE ONLY CDING THAT IS ASSUR IS THAT CDING THAT LEADS TO ZNUS.
A WOMAN IS NOT ALLOWED TO WEAR KLI ZION (WEAPONS) AND ACCORDING TO SOME COMMENTARIES THAT MEANS TIFILIN, WHILE A MAN SHOULD NOT SHAVE HIS ARMPITS OR HIS CROTCH AREA.
FOR A MAN TO DRESS AS A WOMAN FOR HIS OWN RELAXATION ( AND THAT MEANS ALSO GOING OUT IN PUBLIC)AND EVEN SHOPPING IS OK.
THE ARE THOSE THAT EVEN HOLD THAT A WOMAN IS ALLOWED TO WEAR PANTS IF THEY LOOK LIKE WOMANS PANTS.
FASHION HAS CHANGED OVER THE YEARS AND IN ALOT OF CASES IT IS ALMOST IMPOSSIBLE TO TELL THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN MALE & FEMALE CLOTHING, THE MAIN DIFFERENCES BEING IN SKIRTS & DRESSES AND IN SOME CASES SHOES.
MANY WOMEN ARE WEARING MAN-TAILORED FLATS TODAY..SO DOES THAT MEAN THAT THIS HAS BECOME "SIMLAS IYSHAH"?
THERE ARE ALSO COUNTRIES WHERE IT IS CUSTOMARY FOR MEN TO WEAR KILTS,ROBES, AND SARONGS.

SO JUST ENJOY YOUR FEMININTY AND DONT CARE ABOUT WHAT PEOPLE THINK.